Skin in the Game
Created on 2020-10-31T05:13:34-05:00
- Don't give me your opinion show me your portfolio: the best advice is what people are actually doing in practice, not what they are saying you should do.
- People make the best decisions when they have a stake in its outcome.
- Hannurabi's tablet: old (babylonian?) tablet with the rules of commerce, placed in the town square so everyone knows the law or can have it read to them.
- Interventionists cause problems in other countries since they decide to intervene but do not participate in the fighting and do not live with the consequences of their policies.
- Pilot story: incompetent pilots may take risks they don't understand, but will also join in the casualties and so do not propagate
- Do no harm: those who take no risks should not make the decisions.
- Traditional nobility: taking risk of harm to protect others.
- If responsibility is not decentralized, a system will eventually explode.
- Government makes corruption possible.
- Cannot convince someone they are wrong; only reality can.
- Caution against problems only an architect can detect, and will be long gone by the time the problem hits.
- Acting by removal is more powerful than acting by addition.
- Virtue ethics as applying symmetry to relations between individuals.
- When the people taking risks don't pay for them (Bankers) hidden risks will continue until systemic collapse.
- Fools of randomness are purged by nature.
- Those who talk should do; only those who do should talk.
- Stage lights shining on to speakers distracts them.
- Scholars make things more complicated than necessary.
- Designs by people with no skin in the game grow in complexity until collapse.
- "Mental nimbleness of a cauliflower."
- Common law is about the spirit of the law, Regulation is about the letter.
- Deontological libertarianism: The freedom to make mistakes that harm only yourself.
- When people transact they prefer Commonwealths.
- It is dishonorable to allow others to die for you.
- Bob Rubin trade: privatize the profits, socialize the losses; pass the risk of a bad trade on to the public.
- Laws change, ethics don't.
- Companies hate tort law because it places their skin back in the game.
- It is more important that tribes cooperate than all tribes be conjoined in to one.
- Ostrom: communities below particular sizes act as a commons.
- Rhodian Law: if goods must be thrown overboard for the good of all, the cost is equally suffered by all.
- Margaret Mead: Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."
- Generalizing interactions between people only works if there are no asymmetries.
- Thomas Schelling: cellular automata, demonstrating segregation can occur without a single segregationist.
- Dhananjay Gode, Shyam Sunder, Friedrich Hayek: a market consisting only of agents who buy and sell randomly seem to have no more efficiency than "intelligent" markets.
- Giving people something to lose if they disobey authority.
- Whistleblowers: time may eventually vindicate the whistleblower, but it takes much effort to reach through noise created by corporate shills. And the whistleblower is unemployable while they wait.
- Ethical decisions require no dilemma between the particular and the general.
- Cato's injunction: asking why someone does not have a statue instead of why they do.
- Intellectual Yet Idiots do not detect sophistry.
- Dynamic equality: requiring those who hold the highest seats to rotate; or to the possibility of openings being created.
- Negative empiricism: only a small amount of significant data is needed to disprove a hypothesis.
- Periander of Corinth: use laws that are old but food that is fresh.
- Non risk takers do not understand other people are not like them.
- Take as much as you can; but give more than you take.
- Ennius, Cicero: The good is not as good as the absense of bad.
- The successful misfit has conquered more opposition.
- Entrepeneur firms make their money by packaging and selling businesses.
- High bullshit fields: importance of paper is based on prestige of journal. Low bullshit fields: papers go in archival sites.
Dealing with minorities
- Minority rule: when masses who don't care capitulate/appease an intolerant minority. When ~5% of a diffused population becomes an intolerant minority the entire society has to capitulate to it.
- Renormalization groups
- Fractal self-similarity: a small tribe has its own intolerant minority which is appeased, which means the entire tribe appeases, and when enough tribes appease the whole clan appeases, in a recursive way.
- Minority veto: McDonalds survives not through quality, but by being vetoed by the least amount of minorities.
- "Once you have 10% or more women at a party, you cannot serve only beer. But most men will drink wine."
Philosophies of disclosure
- Diogenes: seller should disclose only what the law requires.
- Antipater: seller should disclose everything such that he knows nothing more than the buyer does.